Consolidating your debts into one loan: when it actually saves
1 min read
Rolling your debts into one loan with a lower rate sounds good: a single payment and less interest. But it isn't always cheaper than paying them off in a good order.
The example
- Card A:
- US$5,000 at 40%
- Loan B:
- US$12,000 at 18%
- Card C:
- US$2,000 at 30%
- New loan:
- 20% with a 3% fee
Paying US$1,500 a month, the loan costs you US$3,252.23 in interest and fees; your avalanche plan, US$2,754.12.
Compare it with your plan
With the avalanche, the extra already goes first to the most expensive balance. So the loan has to beat your plan, not your most expensive card.
Add the fee
Many loans charge an origination fee that's added to what you owe. In the example, that fee makes the loan more expensive.
Watch the term
A lower payment stretches the loan and raises the interest, even with a lower rate.
If you do it
Stop using the cards you paid off so you don't run up new balances.
Frequently asked questions
What rate does the loan need to save me something?
Enter the loan in the calculator as a single balance, with the fee added, and compare it with your plan.
What if the loan has a promotional rate?
Check the rate that applies afterwards: if it goes up, the savings can disappear.
Sources
Make your plan
Calculate my planRelated guides
Debt avalanche: pay off the highest rate first
How the avalanche method works and why it almost always costs less interest.
What happens if you only pay the minimums
Paying only the minimum on each debt stretches the plan out for years and multiplies the interest.
Debt snowball: pay off the smallest debt first
How the debt snowball method works for paying off several debts, with a worked example.
Did this help?